Key Findings
Overview
The 2026 Retailer Report Card evaluated the safer chemicals policies and practices of 50 of the largest retailers in the U.S. and Canada. The results show a troubling loss of momentum: overall performance has stalled, nearly half of previously evaluated retailers lost ground, and too few companies are setting measurable goals to achieve safer products. At the same time, leading retailers continue to make progress, demonstrating that it is possible for companies to restrict toxic chemicals and plastics and substitute them with safer solutions.
The 2026 Retailer Report Card reveals:
- Progress towards safer products is stalling. On average, retailers earned a grade of D+, unchanged from the 2024 Retailer Report Card.
- Nearly half of all retailers are backsliding. Twenty-two of the 45 previously evaluated retailers (49%) saw their scores decrease by two or more percentage points, while five dropped by more than 10 percentage points. Sixteen retailers earned failing grades, landing in the 2026 Toxic Hall of Shame.
- Nearly half of retailers reported progress reducing or eliminating toxic chemicals or plastics, but the vast majority have no further public measurable reduction goals. Twenty-two (44%) retailers reported progress since 2024, for example, by phasing out PFAS in food packaging and textiles, bisphenols in receipt paper, and/or PVC in packaging. However, this is a considerable reduction from 34 retailers (68%) reporting similar progress in 2024. Meanwhile, only five (10%) have current public measurable reduction goals, a decline from 22 retailers (44%) in 2024.
- A few retailers continue to lead, and others are making progress. The top scoring retailers were: Apple (A); IKEA (A-); Target (A-); and Sephora (A-). Of retailers previously evaluated, 14 (31%) increased their score by two or more percentage points. Three retailers, Dollar Tree, Sally Beauty, and IKEA, improved their scores by more than 10 percentage points over 2024.
- Ingredient transparency has improved, but is still insufficient. Retailers can’t manage chemicals they do not know are in their products.
- Four retailers, together with other brands, have collaborated under the leadership of ChemFORWARD to develop Safer Chemistry Profiles for beauty and personal care products (Sephora, Target, and Ulta Beauty) and apparel and footwear (lululemon and Target).
- Twenty-one retailers (42%) do not ask their suppliers for the chemical content of products at any level of disclosure for the retailer’s internal use. This is an improvement from 2024, when 54% did not ask suppliers for chemical content.
- Likewise, 21 retailers (42%) do not ask their suppliers to disclose chemical content of products to consumers. This is also an improvement from 2024, when 56% did not ask suppliers to disclose chemical content to consumers.
- More retailers have defined “safer.” Proactively moving to safer solutions, as opposed to simply banning chemicals of concern, requires retailers to first define “safer.” Twelve retailers have adopted definitions of “safer”; Costco, Dollar Tree, and Target have adopted definitions since 2024.
New retailers
Five new retailers were added to the Retailer Report Card this year. The Gap and lululemon, which, among other efforts, both participate in collaborative industry initiatives to align around the identification of chemicals of high concern in manufacturing, earned grades of C and C+ respectively. The other newly evaluated retailers showed little to no evidence of chemicals policies or programs.
- Bath & Body Works: D-
- Lululemon: C+
- The Gap: C
- Wayfair: F
- Williams-Sonoma: F
2026 Retailer Report Card Average Score by Element (% of total possible points)
Corporate Responsibility
As in 2024, 28 retailers (56%) have public corporate chemicals policies to avoid chemicals and/or plastics of high concern in products. However, this top-level finding belies changes among individual retailers, with both advances and backsliding since 2024.
Examples of advances:
- Five Below has developed its first chemicals policy.
- Dollar General, Dollar Tree, Kohl’s, and Macy’s have revised their chemicals policies, making them more protective.
Examples of backsliding:
- Ahold Delhaize and Albertsons have taken down their chemicals policies.
- Amazon has removed a preference for safer alternatives in its chemicals policy.
Transparency
Transparency into chemical ingredients in products remains greatest where it is legally required, for intentionally added chemicals in formulated products such as beauty and personal care products and cleaners. Among formulated products, transparency is still lacking where it is not required, for example, in fragrances and flavors.
Transparency is also lacking for articles, with most retailers in the dark about the identity of the chemicals in the products they are selling. One exception is Apple, which requires its suppliers to participate in its Full Material Disclosure program. Some progress has also been made by some retailers selling textiles: The Gap, IKEA, lululemon, and Target require suppliers to maintain and share an inventory of process chemicals for private-label textiles.
Definitions
Article: an object that, during production, is given a special shape, surface, or design, which determines its function to a greater degree than its chemical composition. Examples include textiles, footwear, and electronics.
Formulated product: a preparation or mixture of chemical substances that can be gaseous, liquid, or solid. Examples include paints, liquid cleaning products, adhesives, coatings, cosmetics, detergents, dyes, inks, or lubricants.
Chemical footprinting and safer chemistry profiles
Understanding which chemicals of concern are used in which products enables retailers to prioritize chemicals for reduction and elimination, then measure progress.
Walmart remained the only retailer to report its chemical footprint, that is, known chemicals of high concern used in a defined set of products. Walmart calculates its chemical footprint for formulated products, primarily beauty and personal care and cleaning products. It reported a reduction in chemicals of high concern per pound of product, reversing an increase reported in 2024.
Sephora, Target, and Ulta Beauty all contributed to the 2026 Beauty and Personal Care Safer Chemistry Profile Report developed by the Know Better, Do Better Collaborative facilitated by ChemFORWARD. This report assessed ingredients as either chemicals of high concern, safer chemicals, and chemicals of unknown concern for over 60,000 products. Likewise, lululemon and Target both contributed to the 2026 Apparel and Footwear Safer Chemistry Profile Baseline Report, also led by ChemFORWARD.
Ban the Bad
Backsliding on reduction and elimination goals
Only five of the 50 retailers assessed have active reduction or elimination goals that publicly identify: 1) the chemical or plastic of concern, 2) the product category, and 3) the target date. Other retailers maintain stated goals, but lack a clear target date. In contrast, in 2024, 22 of the retailers assessed had similar active goals.
Ban the Bad Goals
Retailers that adopted goals to reduce or eliminate highly hazardous chemicals and plastics
| Chemicals / Plastics Targeted for Reduction / Elimination | ||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Retailer | PRIORITY PRODUCTS to which reduction or elimination goal applies | Private label only | GOAL DATE | Bisphenols | Flame Retardants | PFAS | Phthalates | PVC Plastic | EPS/PS Plastics | Other CHCs/PHCs |
| CVS Health | Packaging |
|
2030 |
|
|
|
||||
| Dollar General | Home & automotive cleaning |
|
2026 |
|
||||||
| Personal care |
|
2026 |
|
|||||||
| Hardware |
|
2026 |
|
|||||||
| Dollar Tree | Children’s products |
|
2027 |
|
||||||
| Household chemicals & air fresheners |
|
2028 |
|
|||||||
| The Gap | Packaging |
|
2030 |
|
|
|||||
| Sephora | Beauty products | 2030 |
|
|
|
|
||||
| Packaging | 2030 |
|
|
|
|
|
||||
| TOTAL NUMBER | 2 | 0 | 7 | 1 | 3 | 2 | 4 | |||
This table summarizes active goals retailers have set to reduce and eliminate chemicals and plastics of high concern. This table doesn’t take into account prior goals that retailers have already achieved.
CHCs = Chemicals of High Concern / PHCs = Plastics of High Concern
Notes on this table:
This table summarizes active goals retailers have set to reduce and eliminate chemicals and plastics of high concern. This table doesn’t take into account prior goals that retailers have already achieved.
CHS = Chemicals of High Concern / PHCs = Plastics of High Concern
Numerous state-level chemical restrictions are slated to go into effect in the coming years, but, in a shift from 2024, retailers are largely silent on plans to comply or to go beyond compliance.
Nearly half of retailers reported progress reducing chemicals and plastics
Twenty-two (44%) of the 50 companies assessed reported progress on reducing or eliminating chemicals or plastics of concern since 2024. This is a reduction from 34 retailers (68%) reporting progress in 2024.
Several retailers reported reducing PFAS “forever chemicals” in products and packaging
Since the 2024 Retailer Report Card, the following companies have reported progress on PFAS reduction:
- Apple has reported progress on PFAS reduction that includes ongoing qualification of PFAS alternatives, development of analytical methods, Chemical Hazard Assessments for PFAS alternatives through ChemFORWARD, and enhancement of the Chemical Alternatives Finder to support identification of technically viable, safer PFAS replacements while reducing the potential for regrettable substitutions.
- Burger King, Tim Hortons, Firehouse Subs, and Popeyes have eliminated intentionally added PFAS from North American guest packaging, though not globally.
- The Gap reported improving reporting and testing practices to maintain its elimination of PFAS-based finishings as well as audits of mills to mitigate use of dimethylformamide (DMF), but did not provide quantitative metrics.
- IKEA has finalized and achieved its phase-out of PTFE (a PFAS polymer) in non-stick coated cookware and bakeware, the first major retailer to do so as far as we are aware. The company noted that it took 49 articles (frying pans, pots, saucepans, baking tins, spring forms, etc.) with PTFE non-stick coatings out of its range last year. Given sales volumes, the company shared that this is a significant volume of PFAS that will no longer be in use. IKEA also phased out PFAS refrigerants in appliances. It also set new restrictions on PFAS in fragrances where it may be present as a contaminant.
- McDonald’s eliminated intentionally added PFAS in 99.82% of all guest packaging, including all guest packaging in the United States.
- REI completed its transition away from PFAS in private-label apparel, footwear, packs, and bags.
- Target successfully eliminated PFAS from all private-label products.
Retail progress on PVC, the poison plastic
Three retailers completed the phase-out of PVC packaging over some scope of products since 2024:
Ban the Bad Progress
Retailers that reported progress reducing or eliminating highly hazardous chemicals and plastics since 2024
| Chemicals / Plastics Targeted for Reduction / Elimination | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Retailer | PRIORITY PRODUCTS to which reduction or elimination applies | Bisphenols | Flame Retardants | PFAS | Phthalates | PVC Plastic | EPS/PS Plastics | Other CHCs/PHCs | |
| 7-Eleven | Food packaging |
|
|||||||
| Apple | Cleaners and degreasers |
|
|
|
|
||||
| Electronics |
|
||||||||
| Manufacturing chemicals |
|
||||||||
| Packaging |
|
||||||||
| Best Buy | Electronics |
|
|
||||||
| Manufacturing chemicals |
|
||||||||
| Costco | Textiles |
|
|
|
|
||||
| Products & packaging |
|
|
|
|
|
||||
| IKEA | Cookware |
|
|||||||
| Refrigerants |
|
||||||||
| Kitchen fronts |
|
||||||||
| “Main materials” in products |
|
|
|||||||
| Textiles | |||||||||
| Kohl’s | Textile manufacturing chemicals |
|
|
|
|
||||
| Textiles |
|
|
|
|
|||||
| Kroger | Food packaging |
|
|||||||
| Lowe’s | Receipt paper |
|
|||||||
| Packaging |
|
|
|||||||
| McDonald’s | Food packaging |
|
|||||||
| PetSmart | Receipt paper |
|
|||||||
| Restaurant Brands International | Food packaging |
|
|||||||
| REI | Apparel, footwear, packs & bags |
|
|||||||
| Tents |
|
||||||||
| Sephora | Beauty & personal care |
|
|
|
|
|
|
||
| Target | Packaging |
|
|||||||
| Private label products |
|
||||||||
| Private label denim |
|
||||||||
| The Home Depot | Packaging |
|
|
||||||
| Food service ware |
|
||||||||
| TJX | Packaging |
|
|||||||
| Trader Joe’s | Receipt paper |
|
|||||||
| Ulta Beauty | Beauty & personal care |
|
|
|
|
||||
| Walmart | Cleaning products, beauty & personal care |
|
|
|
|||||
| TOTAL NUMBER | 12 | 3 | 18 | 8 | 5 | 4 | 13 | ||
This table summarizes progress retailers reported reducing or eliminating chemicals and plastics of high concern since 2024, in products, packaging, or manufacturing. This table doesn’t document chemicals or plastics retailers previously reduced or eliminated.
CHCs = Chemicals of High Concern / PHCs = Plastics of High Concern
Notes on this table:
This table summarizes progress retailers reported reducing or eliminating chemicals and plastics of high concern since 2020, in products, packaging, or manufacturing. This table doesn’t document chemicals or plastics retailers previously reduced or eliminated.
* CHS = Chemicals of High Concern / PHCs = Plastics of High Concern
Safer Solutions
More retailers are defining “safer”
Proactively moving to safer solutions, as opposed to simply banning chemicals of concern, requires retailers to first define “safer.” Lacking a clear definition, retailers are left in a reactionary mode, restricting chemicals to comply with new laws or in response to consumer concern. The possibility of regrettable substitutes, that is, chemicals that are at least as hazardous as the original chemical of concern, leaves retailers unable to assure customers of the safety of products, even with chemical restrictions in place.
Apple, Best Buy, Costco, CVS, Dollar Tree, IKEA, lululemon, Sephora, Staples, Target, Walgreens, and Walmart have all adopted definitions for “safer” that are consistent with Washington’s legal definition.
Examples of advances:
- Costco, Dollar Tree, lululemon, and Target have all adopted definitions for “safer” since 2024.
Examples of backsliding:
- Amazon has removed a preference for safer alternatives in its chemicals policy.
Washington State “safer alternative” definition
The law creating the Safer Products for Washington program defines a “safer alternative” as an “alternative that is less hazardous to humans or the environment than the existing chemical or chemical process. A safer alternative to a particular chemical may include a chemical substitute or a change in materials or design that eliminates the need for a chemical alternative.” (RCW 70A.350.010)
As implemented, the Washington state definition of a safer chemical excludes carcinogens, mutagens, reproductive toxicants, endocrine disruptors, and chemicals that are both persistent and bioaccumulative, among other criteria.
Investment in safer solutions
Since 2024, Apple, IKEA, Lowe’s, lululemon, Sephora, Target, and Ulta Beauty all invested in the development of safer solutions. Examples include:
- Apple provided both seed and continued funding to help establish the Safer Chemistry Investment Fund (SCIF), an initiative designed to accelerate the development, commercialization, and adoption of safer chemical alternatives across industry.
- Apple, Sephora, Target, and Ulta Beauty have all contributed to chemical hazard assessments, posted on shared platforms such as ChemFORWARD. Chemical hazard assessments enable manufacturers to make informed ingredient and design choices.
- IKEA has invested to identify and promote safer alternatives to chemicals of concern in cookware and bakeware, textile dyes, and solutions to microplastics. The company’s foundation has also made significant investments to accelerate the transition away from HFCs in refrigerants.
- Lululemon, Target, Sephora, and Ulta Beauty all contributed to safer chemical profiles for beauty and personal care products or apparel and footwear through ChemFORWARD. Safer chemical profiles combine information on ingredient identity and hazard to prioritize chemicals for bans, the need for hazard assessment, and as safer solutions.
- Apple and Amazon, as part of the Electronics Safer Chemistry Collaborative, have worked to identify and implement safer solutions to chemicals of concern, including PFAS, organohalogen flame retardants, and toxic solvents.
Adoption of safer receipt paper
Washington state restricted toxic bisphenols in thermal receipt paper as of January 2026. Toxic-Free Future surveyed 46 retailers in late 2025, asking whether, beyond complying with the ban, they would adopt a safer alternative. Four retailers, Best Buy, Kroger, PetSmart, and Walgreens, confirmed that they had switched to Pergafast, identified by the Washington Department of Ecology as a safer solution. Kroger made the change only in Washington state, while the other three had made the change nationally.
The 2026 Report
- I. Executive Summary
- II. Introduction
- III. Grades
-
IV.
Leaders, Laggards,
and Backsliders - VI. Recommendations
- VII. Resources
- VIII. Methodology
- IX. About this Report
More
Select a retailer
Tell the retailers in the “Toxic Hall of Shame” to step up and protect our health from toxic chemicals and plastics!