Key Findings and Recommendations
Corporate Responsibility
In 2025, Five Below adopted a chemicals management policy that aims to avoid chemicals of high concern in private-label products, and assigned senior management responsibility for implementing this policy. The company should explore opportunities to participate in collaborative processes to reduce and eliminate chemicals of concern.
Transparency
There is no indication that Five Below requires suppliers to disclose chemical ingredients or plastics to the retailer or to consumers, nor that it requires any training or testing to verify ingredients beyond regulatory compliance. Five Below should require detailed ingredient disclosure, verify accuracy, and evaluate its chemical footprint.
Ban the Bad
In 2025, Five Below adopted a restricted substance list (RSL) for its private-label products. The list directs suppliers to avoid PFAS as a class and a few dozen additional chemicals of high concern. The RSL claims to restrict toxics in packaging, but neglects to specify any plastics or chemicals of concern. Five Below should continue to expand its RSL, set time-bound, public goals for reducing chemicals of high concern, and report progress on these goals.
Safer Solutions
There is no indication Five Below has supported the development or sale of verifiably safer products. Five Below should work to ensure toxic chemicals and plastics in products are replaced with safer solutions.
2026 Detailed Analysis of Five Below
Corporate Chemicals Policy
Oversight
Established management responsibilities and incentives
Chemical Footprint Project (CFP)
Collaboration
Actively participates in collaborative process to promote safer chemicals
Public Policy Support
Supports governmental policies to reduce chemicals and plastics of high concern
Supply Chain Disclosure
Requires suppliers to report use of chemicals and plastics in products and packaging to retailer
Accountability
Ensures supply chain accountability
Consumer Ingredient Disclosure
Requires suppliers to disclose use of chemicals and plastics to consumers
Chemical Footprint Calculation
Discloses its chemical footprint
Restricted Substance List (RSL)/Manufacturing Restricted Substance List (MRSL)
Reduction/Elimination Goals
Reduced or Eliminated Chemicals or Plastics of High Concern
Policy
Definition of “safer alternative”
Investment in Safer Solutions
Implementation of Known Safer Solutions
Quantified Safer Products
How does Five Below compare to its competitors?
Previous Grade History
NOTE: Our evaluation criteria changed in 2024. The scores from previous review years through 2021 are based on a different set of criteria measured.
Click or tap on a grade year to review additional details (where available).