Recommendations
The Retailer Report Card is a powerful tool for assessing company progress on chemical safety, and it also provides a roadmap for retailers to improve.
Retailers can and should improve their practices by aligning with and implementing the Essential Elements for a Safer Marketplace: first, by adopting safer chemicals policies; second, by implementing transparency policies so the retailer can understand exactly what chemicals and plastics are in the products and packaging it sells; third, by restricting chemicals and plastics that pose serious risks to health; and fourth, by working to ensure toxic chemicals and plastics are replaced with truly safer solutions.
Trends from the 2026 Retailer Report Card analysis show additional emerging best practices and chronically missed opportunities that retailers can learn.
Every major retailer should do the following:
1. Understand the chemical footprint of your supply chain
You can’t manage what you can’t measure. Companies are increasingly assessing the chemicals in their products and packaging to understand where toxic chemicals are found, where there are safer alternatives, and where there are data gaps that must be filled.
Over the last few years, ChemFORWARD has been developing Safer Chemistry Profile (SCP) Reports for brands and retailers to help companies transform complex chemical inventory and product disclosure data into clear, comparable, hazard-based metrics aligned with the Safer Chemistry Impact Metrics Framework. Organizations can easily quantify their chemical footprints including safer chemistry, identify high-hazard “hot spots” where action is needed, identify where safer alternatives are already being used, target strategic investments to resolve data gaps, and track continuous improvement year-over-year. Retailers should commission Safer Chemistry Profile reports for key product categories.
2. Use class-based definitions in chemical restrictions.
While retailers are taking steps to restrict toxic chemicals across products and packaging, they often struggle to keep up with the ever-growing list of individual chemicals of concern. Restricting chemicals and plastics individually can feel like playing a game of toxic whack-a-mole, where a new PFAS pops up every month—and a new state law pops up the month after that.
Instead of trying to ban every individual chemical of concern, retailers can better protect their business by restricting chemicals as a class where evidence exists that the entire class is problematic for human health and the environment. Class-based restrictions protect health by prohibiting many regrettable substitutions, and they are far more resilient in the face of regulation. Models for this approach are already in use—the AFIRM restricted substances list uses class-based definitions to restrict some of the most common toxic chemicals in the textile industry. Retailers looking for appropriate definitions should also refer to the Ban the Bad list, which offers scientific, class-based restrictions.
3. Prioritize toxic plastics as an element of addressing waste.
Many retailers are being required to prioritize waste and increase recyclability, particularly when it comes to packaging, as a result of state laws requiring it. These efforts should include a priority to reduce toxic plastics and other chemicals, because many widely used toxic plastics, such as PVC, are non-recyclable and may contaminate entire streams of material at recycling facilities. However, too often retailers silo waste and circularity concerns from toxic concerns, to the detriment of both. A circular economy is not a virtue when it keeps toxic chemicals on the shelves. By tracking and targeting types of toxic plastic and other chemicals used in packaging, retailers can fine-tune their circularity work to reduce waste and toxic chemical exposure at the same time.
4. Substitute toxic chemicals and plastics with safer solutions.
It’s not enough for retailers to remove known toxic chemicals and plastics from store shelves: They must also assess the safety of replacement alternatives. Some alternatives may be regrettable substitutions, exposing customers and workers to equally dangerous replacement chemicals. Regrettable substitutions are bad for health, the environment, and also for retailers’ bottom lines. Reformulating a product to make it safer is a necessary and worthy expense, but reformulating a product multiple times as each toxic alternative gets regulated off the market is simply wasteful.
To assess the safety of alternatives, retailers must know what alternatives they’re actually using. For example, many retailers rightly phased out thermal receipts with bisphenols after Washington state’s ban went into effect earlier this year, but several were unable to identify the alternative they had switched to, and one was even stonewalled when it asked its supplier for more safety information. Without sufficient knowledge of the chemical contents or safety of their products, retailers may continue to exacerbate health risks and expose themselves to further regulatory compliance costs.
Retailers should also put their money where their mouth is and invest financial resources in tools like ChemFORWARD to help fill data gaps on alternatives to chemicals of high concern. Several retailers, such as Apple, Sephora, and Target, have been making such investments in recent years. Others should join them.
5. Implement clear standards that move toward safer solutions.
Many retailers are successfully using in-house and third-party standards programs to remove toxic chemicals and plastics from store shelves. In-house badge programs such as Clean at Sephora allow for retailer-specific tailoring of standards and improve customer transparency by highlighting safer products.
However, current badge and standard programs are not all created equal. Some certification or badge programs conflate chemical safety with other environmental concerns, so that customers have no way to know if a product earned its badge by actually restricting toxic chemicals and plastics. Moreover, the most common badge programs and third-party standards retailers use certify the absence of certain toxic chemicals, but not the presence of safer alternatives. Retailers should implement third-party standards that go further by verifying chemical safety, such as Safer Choice, Cradle to Cradle Gold or Platinum, and GreenScreen Certified Gold or Platinum.
6. Reformulate products globally to the strongest standards
As states continue to lead the way in regulating chemical safety, retailers have the opportunity to get ahead of the curve by allowing the strongest standards to set the baseline for their entire national or global footprints. It’s a matter of fairness. If a retailer is already doing the work to get formaldehyde releasers out of hair products it sells in Washington, why would it keep selling the old toxic products across the border in Idaho? A retailer should prioritize the health and wellness of all its customers, no matter where they live.
Additionally, when a large retailer reformulates a product, it’s often cheaper to reformulate that product everywhere using economies of scale than it is to reformulate a subset of that product each time an individual state passes PFAS regulation, for example. Retailers that go beyond minimum compliance to apply the strongest chemical safety standards everywhere they do business understand this is a tremendous investment in consumer health and a future-proof business model.
7. Collaborate to understand chemical ingredients and identify safer solutions.
Industry collaboratives provide retailers access to vital resources, tools, and guidance for improving chemical safety. Every top-scoring company in the 2026 Retailer Report Card participates in at least one such multi-stakeholder network. Collaboratives such as ChemFORWARD’s Know Better Do Better Collaborative, Clean Electronics Production Network, and the ZDHC Foundation are turning best practices into standard practices across wildly different retail sectors. By joining these kinds of networks and participating actively, retailers expand their access to chemical expertise tailored for their business.
The 2026 Report
- I. Executive Summary
- II. Introduction
- III. Grades
-
IV.
Leaders, Laggards,
and Backsliders - V. Key Findings
- VII. Resources
- VIII. Methodology
- IX. About this Report
More
Select a retailer
Tell the retailers in the “Toxic Hall of Shame” to step up and protect our health from toxic chemicals and plastics!